Stoquity Living researchResearch LedgerSlicesMethodologyFor institutionsAbout
Stoquity Research Ledger

Selective Insurance Group Inc. (SIGI)

NASDAQ: SIGI · Fire, Marine & Casualty Insurance · Branchville, NJ

Our rating: Neutral

Neutral reaffirmed at $97.73, moderate conviction, October 28, 2026.

Breaks if: The Neutral call turns Positive if the loss ratio contracts to 63% or below and ROE expands to 15% or above in either of the next two quarterly filings — evidence that underwriting discipline is improving and returns are expanding beyond fair-value pricing. It turns Cautious if the loss ratio rises above 71% in any single quarter over the next four, or if book value per share declines in two consecutive quarters — either condition would signal that the returns currently justifying the P/B premium are eroding.

Key figures

Market value$6.1B
Revenue, last 12 months$5.4B
Net income, last 12 months$511M
Free cash flow, last 12 months$1.1B
Price to earnings11.9×
Free cash flow yield18.7%
Dividend yield1.7%
Operating marginn/a
Return on equity14.7%
Beta to the S&P 5000.30
Volatility, annualized29.9%

Reported quarters

Quarter endingRevenueYear on yearEarnings per shareFree cash flow
September 30, 2026$1.3B−2.5%$2.11$347M
June 30, 2026$1.4B4.5%$2.11$215M
March 31, 2026$1.4B5.7%$1.58$211M
December 31, 2025$1.4B8.6%$2.52$366M
September 30, 2025$1.4B9.3%$1.85$397M
June 30, 2025$1.3B10.9%$1.36$160M
March 31, 2025$1.3B10.3%$1.76$271M
December 31, 2024$1.3B13.1%$1.52$325M

Three-model forecasts for the next quarter

Written November 21, 2026, before the report. Each settles from the SEC filing.

11 ledger entries and 39 corporate events on record. Share price as of November 20, 2026. Research and education only. Not investment advice. Stoquity does not manage money or know your circumstances. Ratings, forecasts and lists are produced by software and AI models and can be wrong. Performance figures are hypothetical, measured on paper against a benchmark, and say nothing certain about the future.